Email Marketing for Small Online Businesses: Matan Guy's Starter System
By Matan Guy · · 7 min read
I'm Matan Guy, and for years I treated email as an afterthought while my energy went into ads and social posts. What changed my mind was simple: every time a platform changed its rules, my reach changed with it. Email marketing is the one channel I've found where I keep the relationship. Here is the starter system I'd set up for any small online business, step by step.
Why your email list is an owned channel
On social media you rent attention. The platform decides who sees your post, and that can shift overnight. Paid ads work, but the moment you stop paying, the traffic stops too, as I explain in my Facebook and Instagram ads guide.
An email list is different. People gave you their address directly, and you reach them without an algorithm in the middle. You still depend on an email provider and inbox filters, so "owned" isn't absolute, but it's the closest thing a small business has to a direct line to its customers.
Consent comes first
The foundation: only email people who clearly asked to hear from you.
- Explicit opt-in. A sign-up box the person ticks or fills in themselves. No pre-checked boxes, no adding everyone who ever bought something to your newsletter by default, and never buying or scraping lists.
- Say what they're signing up for. "Weekly tips and new product updates" sets an expectation you can keep.
- Easy unsubscribe. A clear link in every marketing email, honored promptly. Someone who wants to leave and can't will mark you as spam instead, and that hurts everyone on your list.
- Know the rules where you sell. Anti-spam and privacy laws differ between countries and regions, and they often cover consent, sender identification and unsubscribe handling. This is general information, not legal advice. Check the current requirements for the places your customers live, and ask a professional if you're unsure.
Consent isn't only a legal box. People who chose to be on your list actually read what you send.
A lead magnet that's actually useful
Most visitors won't buy on their first visit, so give them a reason to stay in touch. The best ones solve one small, specific problem connected to what you sell: a size guide, a short checklist, a printable template, a setup walkthrough, a first-order discount if that fits your margins.
My rule: if I wouldn't be happy to receive it myself, it's not good enough. A vague "free ebook" full of filler teaches people your emails aren't worth opening.
The four core automations
Automations are emails that send themselves when someone does something. Set them up once and review them every few months.
Welcome sequence
Triggered when someone joins. The first email delivers what you promised, right away. The next two or three introduce who you are, what you sell and why it's different, and point to your most helpful content or best-selling products. This is where trust starts, the same way I describe in my piece on personal branding for founders.
Browse and cart reminders
Triggered when a known subscriber views a product or leaves items in the cart without buying. One or two short emails: a reminder, answers to common hesitations like shipping and returns, and a clear link back. Only send these where your tracking and consent setup make them legally allowed, and keep the tone helpful rather than pushy.
Post-purchase
Triggered by an order. Thank the customer, tell them what happens next, and help them get value from the product with care tips, how-to guides or setup help. Later, ask for a review, and only then suggest related products.
Win-back
Triggered when a customer hasn't bought or engaged for a while. The window depends on how often people naturally buy what you sell. Remind them what's new, ask honestly whether they still want to hear from you, and make leaving easy. If they stay silent, stop emailing them.
| Automation | Trigger | Goal | Key message |
|---|---|---|---|
| Welcome sequence | New subscriber joins | Build trust and deliver the promise | "Here's what you asked for, and here's who we are" |
| Browse / cart reminder | Viewed or carted without buying (where allowed) | Help an undecided shopper decide | "Still thinking it over? Here are the answers you might need" |
| Post-purchase | Order placed | Satisfaction, reviews, repeat purchase | "Thank you. Here's how to get the most out of it" |
| Win-back | No purchase or engagement for a set period | Re-engage or clean the list | "We'd love to stay in touch. Do you still want these emails?" |
A simple weekly broadcast rhythm
On top of automations, I send one broadcast a week. It's frequent enough to stay remembered and manageable enough to keep up.
A rotation that keeps it from feeling repetitive:
- A useful tip related to your products or your customers' problems.
- A story about how something is made, a mistake you learned from, or a customer question you answered.
- A product focus, a new arrival or a best-seller, with a real reason to care.
- A roundup: your best content, answers to common questions, what's coming next.
Subject lines and emails people actually read
The subject line has one job: make the right person want to open. Clear usually beats clever. Say what's inside, keep it short enough for a phone, and never promise something the email doesn't deliver.
Inside the email:
- One main idea and one main call to action. If everything is important, nothing is.
- Write like you'd talk to one customer. Short paragraphs, plain words, your real name as the sender where it fits.
- Lead with the useful part. People scan.
- Check it on a phone before sending.
Segmentation basics
Segmentation means sending different emails to different groups. Start with three simple splits:
- Customers vs. subscribers who haven't bought yet. Their questions are different.
- Engaged vs. unengaged. People who opened or clicked recently, and people who haven't for a long time.
- Interest, based on what they bought or which lead magnet they chose.
Even one of these makes your emails more relevant.
Deliverability basics
A great email is useless if it lands in spam. Three foundations matter most.
- Authenticate your domain. SPF is a record that lists which servers may send email for your domain. DKIM adds a digital signature showing the message really came from you and wasn't changed on the way. DMARC tells inbox providers what to do with messages that fail those checks and sends you reports. Your email provider's help pages walk you through adding these records.
- Keep the list clean. Remove addresses that bounce, and stop mailing people who haven't engaged in a long time.
- Avoid spammy practices. No purchased lists, no misleading subject lines, no sudden huge sends from a brand-new domain, and no hiding the unsubscribe link.
What to measure
Track a few numbers weekly and connect them to decisions, as in my marketing metrics dashboard.
- Open rate. Useful as a rough trend, but less reliable than it used to be: some email apps load images automatically, which can register opens that didn't really happen. Compare it against your own history, not against numbers you read online.
- Click rate. A better signal of interest. Low clicks usually point to a weak offer or an unclear call to action.
- Conversions and revenue from email. Use your store's data and consistent link tagging to see which emails lead to orders.
- Unsubscribe and spam-complaint rates. If they rise, you're sending too often or sending the wrong things to the wrong people.
Watch your own trends over time instead of chasing industry averages. More about how I work is on the about page.
FAQ
How big should my list be before I start emailing?
Start as soon as the first person subscribes. The welcome sequence works the same for one subscriber or a thousand.
How often should a small business send marketing emails?
Once a week is a sensible starting point for broadcasts, plus your automations. Watch unsubscribes and engagement, and adjust from there.
Do I need an expensive email platform to begin?
No. Many email providers offer entry-level plans that include sign-up forms, basic automations and segmentation. Choose one that integrates with your store, supports domain authentication and makes unsubscribing easy.